RBX Is Appealing the Spotify Bot-Streaming Dismissal and the Fight Over Fake Streams Isn't Over
Rapper RBX is taking his bot-streaming case against Spotify to the Ninth Circuit. The appeal follows a California federal court’s October dismissal of his class action with prejudice, meaning he cannot bring the same claims again in that district court. The appellate court has not ruled on the case.
RBX, whose legal name is Eric Collins, filed a notice of appeal on November 6, according to Digital Music News and AllHipHop. Spotify is the sole defendant in the appeal, Digital Music News reported.
What the lawsuit alleged, and what the judge decided
RBX’s lawsuit alleged that bot-generated streams inflated royalty payouts for some catalogs and reduced the share available to other rights holders. The complaint pointed to Drake’s catalog as an example, but Drake was not a defendant. Its claim that alleged fraud diverted at least $600 million was RBX’s estimate, not a finding by the court, as Music Business Worldwide reported.
The case focused in part on RBX’s allegation that Spotify enforced its anti-fraud rules selectively, strictly against some artists, while failing to act against artificial streams benefiting high-profile catalogs. Those claims remain allegations. The court did not determine that the claims about streams in Drake’s catalog were true.
In October, Judge Josephine L. Staton of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California ruled that RBX had not pleaded enough facts to support his negligence and California Unfair Competition Law claims. The court found the selective-enforcement allegations conclusory and dismissed the case with prejudice. Music Business Worldwide’s report includes the ruling and its reasoning; Bloomberg Law also covered the dismissal.
The appeal is underway, not decided
A notice of appeal starts the appellate process; it is not a ruling on the merits. Digital Music News reports that more detailed appellate filings are still to come. The Ninth Circuit is expected to set a briefing schedule, then decide whether to affirm the district court’s dismissal. As of November 10, there is no Ninth Circuit ruling in RBX’s case.
That distinction matters. The district court’s dismissal with prejudice stands unless the appeals court changes it. The appeal keeps RBX’s challenge alive, but it does not prove the original allegations or guarantee that the lawsuit will return to the trial court. Digital Music News’ appeal report outlines the current status.
Why fake streams can affect artists beyond the target
The case also points to a broader issue: how streaming fraud can affect a shared royalty pool. The U.S. Copyright Office explains that streaming services commonly allocate a portion of revenue to royalty pools and that, in a pro-rata system, rights holders’ shares depend on the proportion of eligible plays. Fraudulent streams can divert money from rights holders whose plays are legitimate, according to the Office’s notice of inquiry on music-streaming fraud.
That does not mean every artist receives one fixed per-stream rate, or that every unusual listening pattern is fraud. Actual payouts vary. But if artificial plays take a larger share of a pool, legitimate plays may represent a smaller share. The Copyright Office also noted possible effects on streaming data used for playlist decisions, artist planning, and music discovery.
The Office opened its inquiry after a congressional request for information on streaming fraud and its effects across the music industry. It is gathering public input on how schemes work, their economic effects, current detection and prevention efforts, and possible solutions. The inquiry is a separate process from RBX’s lawsuit; it does not decide the claims against Spotify.
Deadline update: The original notice listed November 23, 2026, for initial comments. The Copyright Office later extended that deadline. Initial comments are now due December 18, 2026, by 5:00 p.m. Eastern; reply comments are due January 29, 2027, by 11:59 p.m. Eastern, according to the Federal Register extension. The Office provides inquiry details and submission information on its music-streaming fraud page.
Practical steps artists can take
Bot streams hurt every artist’s share, not just the artist targeted by fraud
In a pooled royalty system, artificial plays can shift the share of revenue available to legitimate plays. Keep in mind that payout calculations differ across services and agreements; a stream count alone does not determine what an artist will be paid.
Audit your streaming data for suspicious spikes
Review your distributor and platform dashboards regularly. Look for sudden changes in streams, listener locations, or activity that do not line up with your release, promotion, or audience patterns. An unexpected spike is a reason to investigate, not proof of fraud.
Report suspected fraud to your distributor and the platform
If activity looks unusual, contact your distributor and use the streaming platform’s reporting process. Include the track, dates, affected territories if available, and a clear description of what you noticed. The Copyright Office’s inquiry describes reporting and detection as part of the wider industry response, but procedures differ between companies.
Document anomalies with screenshots and dates
Save dated screenshots of dashboards, distributor messages, campaign details, and any relevant playlist or promotion information. Keep copies of your reports and responses. A clear timeline can help the distributor or platform review what happened.
Know the updated Copyright Office deadline
Artists and other members of the public can submit comments to the Copyright Office. The current initial-comment deadline is December 18, 2026, not the November 23 date in the original notice. The Federal Register extension includes the updated dates and submission details.
Publishing
Artists who own or control their master recordings may also collect eligible SoundExchange royalties when their music is played on qualifying non-interactive digital services.
Radio-friendly talking points: 5–10 minute segment
- Minute 1–2: RBX filed a November 6 appeal to the Ninth Circuit after his Spotify class action was dismissed with prejudice.
- Minute 2–3: Explain the difference between a district court dismissal and an appeal. The Ninth Circuit has not ruled.
- Minute 3–5: Break down RBX’s allegations about bot streams and selective enforcement. Emphasize that allegations are not court findings, and Drake was not a defendant.
- Minute 5–7: Explain how fake plays may dilute shares in a pooled royalty system, and why there is no single universal per-stream rate.
- Minute 7–8: Share practical steps: check dashboards, report suspicious activity, and preserve dated records.
- Minute 8–10: Note the Copyright Office’s separate inquiry and updated initial-comment deadline of December 18, 2026.
RBX’s appeal is one thread in a larger debate over fake streams, royalty allocation, and how platforms identify suspicious activity. The next key steps are the Ninth Circuit’s briefing schedule and the Copyright Office’s review of public comments.
Power JDM The Beat is online at PowerJDM.com and PowerJDM.com/app.
