Ye and Ty Dolla $ign Sued Over Vultures and the Claim Is an MP3 Sent in 2018

A music file sent years ago is now at the center of a copyright lawsuit. Producers Jae Deal and Marlon Barrow allege that material they made in 2018 was used in Ye and Ty Dolla $ign’s Vultures releases without a license, credit or payment. The complaint says Barrow sent Ty Dolla $ign an MP3-but no written agreement for using the music was signed. Music Business Worldwide reported the suit was filed in Los Angeles federal court on November 6, 2026.

These are the producers’ allegations, not court findings. Nothing has been decided, and the coverage has not yet laid out the defendants’ response.

What the producers allege

The complaint identifies the 2018 recording as “Joint 2,” which Deal and Barrow say they co-own. They allege that Ty Dolla $ign asked for a copy of the music for possible use on an upcoming project, and Barrow sent him an MP3 by text. According to the complaint, the understanding was that higher-quality files and stems would be provided only after the parties signed a written agreement. The producers say no such agreement was reached, and Barrow did not send the stems. Those details appear in the complaint and in Music Business Worldwide’s report.

The producers further allege that Ty Dolla $ign shared the MP3 with Ye and that versions of “Vultures” later incorporated their material without permission. They claim that Barrow received a producer credit but no compensation, while Deal was not credited or paid. The complaint seeks damages and other remedies; those requests are not awards, and the court has not ruled on them. The complaint outlines the claims and requested relief.

The key distinction is simple: sending someone a file is not necessarily the same as granting permission to use it. But what a particular exchange means legally depends on the facts, the rights involved and any agreements or communications between the parties.

The paperwork lesson, and a separate Flo Milli case

This lawsuit is part of a week’s worth of music-rights news that puts paperwork in focus. In a separate case, a California judge dismissed producer Shamar Deal’s copyright claims over Flo Milli’s “Never Lose Me” and “Ron Artest.” The judge found that Deal had not shown he had a valid signed exclusive license to the beat. The ruling turned on the licensing paperwork, not on a decision that the songs did or did not infringe copyright. Music Business Worldwide reported on the dismissal.

The cases are different and should not be confused. One is a new suit alleging unlicensed use after an MP3 was shared; the other ended in dismissal because the plaintiff did not establish the rights needed to bring his claims. Together, they offer a practical reminder: clear records can matter years after a file changes hands, and paperwork can affect whether someone can enforce a claimed right.

Artist protection: four habits worth keeping

The following points are general information, not legal advice. The U.S. Copyright Office explains that music can involve separate copyrights in the sound recording and in the underlying musical work, and that permission may be needed from relevant rights holders. Its guide to samples, interpolations and beat licensing explains the basics.

Document every file you send and receive. Keep dated copies of messages, emails, file-transfer links, versions, stems and session notes. Record who created and owns each part of the music, and what the file was shared for. A clear paper trail can help everyone understand what was discussed and what still needs approval.

A “demo” is not a license. A file sent for listening, feedback or possible collaboration should not be treated as automatic permission for a commercial release. Spell out in writing what the recipient may do with it, whether they can share it, and what additional approval is required before release.

Confirm ownership before using material. A track may include a sound recording and a separately owned composition. Ask who controls each relevant right, and confirm that the people granting permission have authority to do so. The Copyright Office says a transfer of copyright ownership generally must be in a writing signed by the rights owner or an authorized agent; licensing arrangements can have their own terms. See Copyright Act, section 204 and the Copyright Office’s permission guidance.

If a claim arrives, respond through counsel, not social media. Preserve the files and communications, avoid deleting or editing relevant records, and get legal advice before making public statements or responding to a demand. A public post can escalate a dispute without clarifying who owns what or what any agreement says.

Publishing

Artists who own or control their master recordings may also collect eligible SoundExchange royalties when their music is played on qualifying non-interactive digital services.

That royalty stream is distinct from resolving sample or licensing rights. SoundExchange explains its digital performance royalties and eligible services.

Radio-friendly talking points

5–10-minute segment cues:

  1. The headline (1 minute): Two producers have sued Ye and Ty Dolla $ign, alleging music from a 2018 recording was used in Vultures without a license or payment. Stress that the case is active and nothing has been decided.
  2. The MP3 detail (1–2 minutes): The complaint alleges an MP3 was sent for possible use, while higher-quality files and stems were held back pending a written agreement. Sending a file and clearing its commercial use are separate questions.
  3. The paperwork theme (1–2 minutes): Briefly contrast this suit with the separate Flo Milli case, where a judge dismissed claims over whether the plaintiff had a valid signed exclusive license. The cases have different facts and outcomes.
  4. Practical habits (2–3 minutes): Talk through file logs, written permissions, ownership checks for both recordings and compositions, and keeping communication professional if a dispute arises.
  5. Close (30 seconds–1 minute): Remind listeners that a lawsuit is a set of allegations, not a ruling. Point them to the complaint and the linked reporting for the details.

This is a developing legal matter. Power JDM The Beat’s coverage is informational; the PowerJDM.com site and Power JDM app are available for station updates.