Flo Milli Kept "Never Lose Me" Because Nobody Signed the Paperwork
The plaintiff lost, not Flo Milli. A federal judge dismissed the copyright lawsuit over “Never Lose Me” after finding that Shamar Deal could not prove he had acquired the exclusive beat rights he claimed. Deal’s lawyer says he plans to appeal, so the dispute may not be finished. (Billboard; Music Times)
On November 6, 2026, Judge André Birotte Jr. dismissed Deal’s copyright lawsuit against Flo Milli, Babyface Ray and 42 Dugg. The case centered on “Never Lose Me,” which samples “Ron Artest,” a track by Babyface Ray and 42 Dugg. The ruling turned on a missing signature, not a finding that the songs had no shared material. (Billboard; Culture + Times)
Deal had claimed he bought a 10-year exclusive license to the beat “Youu” on the marketplace Traktrain in 2019. He said he paid producer Gerreaux Katana $200 for the license, then alleged the beat was later licensed to Babyface Ray and 42 Dugg for “Ron Artest,” which Flo Milli sampled for her hit. The lawsuit sought $1 million, according to Hip Hop Unlocked.
Why the case was dismissed
The judge ruled that Deal’s purported exclusive license was invalid because it lacked the producer’s signature. Federal copyright law generally requires a written, signed instrument to transfer copyright ownership. An exclusive license is treated as a transfer of ownership for this purpose; the statute excludes nonexclusive licenses from that definition. (U.S. Copyright Office, Chapter 2; Billboard)
That distinction mattered. Deal’s claim depended on having the exclusive rights he said he had purchased. Without a valid transfer of those rights, the judge found he could not prove he owned what he was suing over. The court dismissed the case without giving Deal an opportunity to amend it, according to Billboard and Culture + Times.
The ruling is narrow. It does not decide that “Never Lose Me” and “Ron Artest” contain no shared material, or that every beat license bought online is invalid. It addresses whether Deal had a properly documented exclusive transfer that allowed him to bring these claims. (Music Times; Culture + Times)
The appeal is still ahead
Deal’s attorney, Larry Zerner, said his client intends to appeal to the Ninth Circuit. Zerner argued that Katana listed the beat as exclusive, set its price, accepted payment and confirmed the sale. That is the plaintiff’s position, not a decision from the appeals court. As of the latest reports, the appeal was planned; the Ninth Circuit had not yet ruled on it. (Billboard; Music Times)
For now, the dismissal is a win for the defendants in the trial court. Babyface Ray’s and distributor EMPIRE’s attorney welcomed the decision, Billboard reported. Flo Milli and 42 Dugg did not immediately respond to the publication’s requests for comment. (Billboard)
The paperwork lesson for artists and producers
The headline takeaway is simple: an “exclusive” label on a listing, or proof that money changed hands, may not be enough to establish an exclusive transfer in court. The license needs to clearly document what rights are being granted and be signed by the copyright owner or an authorized agent, under the federal law applied in this case. (U.S. Copyright Office, Chapter 2; Billboard)
Producers: Get every beat license signed before you sell it
If you are selling exclusive rights, make sure the agreement records the transfer and is signed by the rights holder, or an authorized representative. A beat listing and payment confirmation can document a sale, but this ruling shows why producers should not leave the actual license unsigned. (U.S. Copyright Office, Chapter 2; Billboard)
Buyers: Confirm the seller owns the beat and can license it exclusively
Before paying for an exclusive license, check who owns the beat and whether the seller has authority to grant the rights promised. The person uploading a track to a marketplace is not automatically the owner of every right in it. That is a practical safeguard drawn from the ownership issue at the center of Deal’s case. (Music Times; U.S. Copyright Office, Chapter 2)
Do not assume an unsigned document will hold up years later
A missing signature can become a major problem long after a beat has been bought, recorded, sampled and released. Keep copies of the signed agreement, payment record and any written communications that explain the rights being granted. Documentation does not guarantee that every dispute will be resolved in your favor, but it helps establish what the parties agreed to.
Know the difference between exclusive and non-exclusive
An exclusive license gives the licensee rights that others (including, in some cases, the original owner) may not use during the agreement’s scope. A non-exclusive license can allow the rights holder to license the same material to other people. Federal law treats an exclusive license as a transfer of copyright ownership for the relevant statutory rule, while a non-exclusive license is not treated that way. Read the terms rather than relying on a marketplace label. (U.S. Copyright Office, Chapter 1; U.S. Copyright Office, Chapter 2)
Watch the official video
Watch Flo Milli’s “Never Lose Me” official video on YouTube.
Publishing
Artists who own or control their master recordings may also collect eligible SoundExchange royalties when their music is played on qualifying non-interactive digital services.
Radio segment cues: 5–10 minutes
- Minute 1–2: Set up the story: the plaintiff lost the case; Flo Milli was not the plaintiff. A judge dismissed the lawsuit against her, Babyface Ray and 42 Dugg.
- Minute 2–4: Walk listeners through the alleged beat chain: “Youu,” the claimed Traktrain purchase, “Ron Artest,” then “Never Lose Me.” Make clear these are the claims and context reported about the case.
- Minute 4–6: Explain the signature issue in plain language. Why can an exclusive license require more than a listing, receipt or email?
- Minute 6–8: Discuss what the ruling did, and did not, decide. The dismissal was about Deal’s claimed ownership, not a ruling that the songs shared no material.
- Minute 8–10: Share the practical checklist: verify ownership, define exclusive or non-exclusive rights, get signatures, keep the paperwork, and note that Deal plans to appeal.
More music and industry news is available at PowerJDM.com and through the PowerJDM.com/app.
